What Attorneys Need To Know About Scars

scarScars are a normal consequence of wound healing.  Frequently, scars are “an issue” when an attorney evaluates damages in a medical/legal form.

Scars are commonly characterized by the depths of the elevated tissue, pigment shape, and orientation.  Although scars often improve with time, the human body may yield abnormal scars.  These subtypes are “hypertrophic scars” or “keloids.”.  Hypertrophic scars may be raised and red, and distort adjacent body parts. Keloidal scars grow beyond the zone of injury.

Multiple factors influence the ultimate quality of the resultant scar.  Certainly, a history needs to be taken as to the mechanism of the trauma.  An avulsion, where there is loss of tissue, would be a more problematic scar than a “simple” cut.  Furthermore, the region of the body where the wound lies is important.  Certain areas, such as the shoulder or sternum, frequently widen and become raised above the surrounding skin.  This is possibly due to high skin tension in all directions in these anatomic sites.

If a wound follows a relaxed skin line, a more optimal cosmetic or functional result will become evident.  Multiple smaller scars heal better than one long straight scar.  Smaller scars are not subject to the “bowstring” effect of a longer scar.

When there is tissue loss, skin tension is increased during the closure of the wound, and the scar will probably widen.  The wound edges are often necrotic, and this will increase the amount of scar formation with time.  In addition, detrimental foreign bodies may be evident.

Burn scars are particularly problematic due to loss of delicate skin structures through the noxious action of the heat, which leads to an increased amount of tension.

A red hyper vascular scar is at a higher risk for hypertrophic formation.  Progressive measures, such as silicone gel sheets would be helpful, along with the possibility of laser intervention.  Although multiple methods of treatment exist, one could recommend silicone sheets, intralesional corticosteroids, and/or surgery.

Pressure therapy has been used, although there are mixed reports as to its effectiveness. Radiotherapy remains controversial because of reports of carcinogenesis following the procedure.  Laser therapy has shown mixed results.

Promising therapies, however, include additional injections. These are utilized to alter the immune system.

Pain and itching is commonly associated with scarring.  There is some evidence that these symptoms may persist.

scarIn Summary, the skin is a complex organ, derived from multiple germinal layers.

Skin heals by the formation of a fibrous scar.  Once an injury sections the deeper layers of skin, there will always be a scar.  In some locations it may be conspicuous and in other locations it may be disfiguring.

Scars are a source of distress and anguish.  Studies show that employment prospects may be lowered, as some potential employers may be disturbed by the appearance of scars. Dr. Fritz Gibson, a British Plastic Surgeon, wrote, “by your scars, you’ll be judged.”

It is always important to have a Psychiatrist see a patient who exhibits symptoms of anxiety and/or depression from a scarring event.  Psychiatrists are often able to help a patient deal with the permanency of scarring, and the cosmetic and functional results.

They can also add depth to a plastic surgeon’s evaluation of a patient’s anatomic or functional abnormality or disability.

About The Author

The Expert Institute publishes thousands of unique articles containing case analyses submitted by expert witnesses working in different areas of practice. All of our expert articles are submitted by nationally-recognized professionals and reviewed by The Expert Institute's editorial team.


no imageThis expert is a board-certified plastic surgeon who is in active practice, and holds memberships in several prestigious plastic surgery societies like the American Society of Plastic Surgeons and the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons. Furthermore, he has considerable experience with the procedure in question and is capable of reviewing this case.

Location: FL
BS, Florida State University
MD, Drexel University College of Medicine
Internship, General Surgery, Eastern Virginia Medical School
Residency, General Surgery, Eastern Virginia Medical School
Residency, General Surgery, Monmouth Medical Center
Residency, Plastic Surgery, Louisiana State University
Board Certified, Plastic Surgery
Member, American Society of Plastic Surgeons
Member, American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons
Member, American College of Surgeons
Member, Southeastern Society of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeons
Member, Greater Miami Society of Plastic Surgeons Florida Medical Association
Honors, Chief Resident, Plastic Surgery, Louisianna State University
Former, Former Clinical Instructor, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, Louisiana State University
Former, President, Miami Society of Plastic Surgeons
Current, Chief of Plastic Surgery, a major Florida hospital center
Current, Instructor, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, a major southern medical university