Given the technical and complex nature of modern litigation, expert witness testimony is becoming increasingly important. Experts apply their experience and subject matter expertise to help the trier-of-fact understand industry-specific terms and processes. Experts can be an extremely valuable asset to either a plaintiff or defense attorney. To showcase the value of expert witness testimony, The Expert Institute has compiled a list of recent headline-grabbing cases where an expert witness made a significant impact on the case outcome.
1.) Mark Cuban Defeats Insider Trading Allegations
When the SEC accused Mark Cuban of insider trading, the entrepreneurial businessman and current owner of an NBA team, the Dallas Mavericks was determined to prove his innocence. It took five years but with the help of a securities expert witness , Cuban was exonerated of all charges. The expert witness, and former SEC executive, convinced the jury that Cuban did not break any laws. He only traded on information that was immaterial and publicly available at the time of the sale in question.
2.) Apple Scores Win in High-Profile Patent Litigation
One highly talented and persuasive CPA convinced a federal jury in a high-profile patent litigation suit that Samsung Electronics Co. infringed on Apple, Inc. patents. Testimony by Apple’s economic damages expert witness resolved a dispute among jurors. The dispute concerned whether $178 million of the more than $230 million of profits that Samsung earned was attributable to Samsung’s operating costs as the South Korean-based company claimed. The jury, swayed by expert witness testimony, ultimately awarded a $290 million judgment in Apple’s favor.
3.) Chicago Man Exonerated and Awarded $25 Million
16 years after he was wrongly imprisoned for a murder he did not commit, Thaddeus Jimenez was finally exonerated. Hardworking lawyers spent years attempting to prove malicious prosecution and violation of due process. Their case was greatly strengthened by the testimony of a former FBI agent and expert on police investigations. Jimenez’s police activities expert witness testified on reasonable practices for police investigations. He exposed the coercive tactics employed by a former Chicago police detective investigating the murder that then 13-year-old Jimenez was jailed for. He explained how radically his actions deviated from industry standards. The Seventh Circuit ruled in favor of Jimenez. Therefore, it awarded him $25 million, one of the most substantial verdicts in Chicago’s history.
4.) Johnson & Johnson Pays $8 Million for Defective Hip Implant Device
Johnson & Johnson was forced to recall 93,000 defective implants used in total hip arthroplasty surgeries following evidence that their DePuy Orthopedics artificial hip implants caused significant health complications. The first trial against the healthcare giant on this issue demonstrated that the DePuy device had multiple design defects. A biomedical engineering expert witness testified on behalf of the plaintiff, explaining that J&J ignored red flags in their internal data that their product deformed 10 times more than industry standards had allowed. Another expert witness explained aspects of the product’s design which made it inadequate. As a result, the jury agreed with the plaintiff’s experts and held that J&J must pay $8 million in damages.
5.) Ethan Couch and the Affluenza Defense
A 16-year-old boy made national headlines when he avoided jail time for a drunk driving episode that left four people dead. The defense psychology expert witness for Ethan Couch described the young boy as suffering from a mental health condition called “affluenza.”. The term, coined by mental health therapist Jessie O’Neill in her 1997 book “The Golden Ghetto: The Psychology of Affluence,” describes an inability to appreciate the consequences of one’s actions. The judge was swayed by the expert witness’s testimony. Subsequently, he chose to sentence Couch to 10 years of probation, rather than the 20 year jail sentence prosecutors sought.